Backlash Grows as Phoenix Suns Consider J.R. Smith for Head Coaching Role Despite Inexperience Concerns
The Phoenix Suns have sparked widespread debate with reports suggesting they plan to interview former NBA star J.R. Smith for their head coaching vacancy. While Smith’s name is well known across the league for his championship-winning playing days, the prospect of him stepping into a head coaching role with no prior experience has led to strong criticism and skepticism from analysts, fans, and insiders alike.
Decorated Playing Career, Unproven as Coach
J.R. Smith, who entered the league in 2004 as the 18th overall pick, carved out a successful 16-year career with stops in New Orleans, Denver, New York, Cleveland, and Los Angeles. He is a two-time NBA champion—first with the Cleveland Cavaliers in 2016 and later with the Lakers in 2020—and earned a reputation as a sharpshooter and athletic wing.
Since retiring, Smith has taken an unconventional path, enrolling at North Carolina A\&T State University and even joining the school’s golf team. While his return to education was widely praised, his sudden emergence as a coaching candidate—particularly at the NBA level—has raised more questions than excitement.
Concerns About Readiness and Experience
Critics argue that the Suns, a team with high aspirations and a star-studded roster, cannot afford to take a gamble on an unproven coach. Smith has never held a formal coaching position at the collegiate or professional level, nor has he worked as an assistant. His potential appointment is seen by many as a high-risk move, particularly for a franchise in need of stability and tactical leadership.
Phoenix has faced backlash in the past for appointing coaches with little to no head coaching experience, and many fear this could be a repeat of those missteps. While Smith may offer energy and a strong connection with players, his lack of coaching credentials has left many questioning the logic behind his candidacy.
History of Communication Issues
Smith’s own playing career also featured moments of friction. Notably, during his time with the Cleveland Cavaliers, former coach Tyronn Lue benched Smith in 2018 without direct communication—delivering the news via text. Smith later criticized the lack of transparency, saying he wished there had been more honest dialogue. Incidents like this have led some to question how Smith might manage locker room dynamics and relationships in a leadership role.
The Suns’ Crucial Decision
For the Phoenix Suns, who are seeking a coach capable of leading them deep into the playoffs, the decision to entertain Smith’s candidacy is a bold one. With a core that includes elite talent and expectations of immediate success, the team’s coaching hire could significantly impact its short-term future.
Some believe Smith could bring a fresh, player-focused approach and unique perspective to the bench. But others argue that in a league where coaching strategy, game management, and leadership are critical, proven experience should take priority.
As the Suns continue to evaluate candidates, the J.R. Smith interview has ignited a larger conversation about what qualities truly matter in a modern NBA head coach. The coming weeks will determine whether Phoenix is willing to take a chance on a name with star power but little track record in coaching—or whether they’ll prioritize a more traditional, experienced leader to guide their franchise forward.
